Free Electron Laser Commissioning Meeting
Friday, 20 Mar 98
Recorder: C. Bohn
Next Meeting
- Date: 27 Mar 98
- Time: "0845"-0945
- Place: FEL Facility Break Room
(Note: C. Bohn will be out of town from late 25 Mar through late
29 Mar, and so J. Fugitt will officiate and document next week's meeting.)
Agenda for Next Meeting
Item Person Responsible Time
---- ------------------ --------
Status of Open Action Items All 5 min
Scheduling and Commissioning Program Fugitt/All 25 min
CSR Simulations Li 15 min
New Issues All 5 min
Agenda for next week All 5 min
This Week's Attendees
S. Benson, J. Bisognano, C. Bohn, J. Boyce, S. Buettmann (Phy Div), R.
Campisi, D. Douglas, J. Fugitt, A. Hofler, K. Jordan, G. Krafft, R. Lauze,
R. Legg, R. Li, L. Merminga, J. Mitchell (Phy Div), G. Neil, D. Oepts, J.
Parkinson, P. Piot, M. Shinn, Q.-S. Shu, T. Siggins, R. Walker, B. Yunn, 3
other Phy Div members
Closed Action Items
- Douglas: Update spreadsheet code to reflect "song-sheet" nomenclature.
Status: Complete.
- Bohn: Test www logbook and shift-summary entries via a trial shift log.
Status: It appears that FLOG entries are not automatically transcribed in
the shift log. We likewise noted this during the week's commissioning
activities. A. Hofler has been apprised.
- Fugitt/Physics: Resolve how to verify spot size on the GEN targets.
Status: As of this morning, the plan is to install a ceramic viewer with a
hole along with a monitoring camera. The ceramic will tolerate up to 80 ľA
current.
- Bohn: Check with Parkinson about reactivating the NEG in the
energy-recovery dump line. Status: The NEG pump did not need to be
reactivated.
- Boyce: Resolve with Physics Division people the time needed to
irradiate each GEN target, and arrange for one of them to give an overview
of the irradiation procedure at next week's meeting. Status: Warm targets
will require 8-10 hours of 2 ľA irradiation, and cold targets will require
5-6 hours of 2 ľA irradiation. M. Seely gave the overview this morning.
- FEL WBS Managers/Integrators: Attempt log-on to www-based ARR system.
Status: J. Boyce contacted the affected individuals so they know who they
are. C. Bohn attempted log-on and worked with Boyce through a few bugs in
the process.
- Douglas: Update spreadsheet code to propagate zero-current beam to the
straight-ahead dump given the 60 pC PARMELA settings. Status: Complete
and running on a workstation in the FEL Control Room.
Items of Discussion
With this week's successful commissioning of the injector and linac with
cw electron beam up to about 8 ľA, we are ready to begin GEN target
irradiation and will start ASAP this afternoon. M. Seely led a discussion
of the associated procedure and technical details. Some highlights are:
- The FEL operator, not the Physics Division participant, will have final
say in the respective shift activities. We all expect collegial
communications, but the attendees felt it important to establish
unambiguously the "crew chief".
- Per Physics Division request a couple of weeks ago, GEN target
irradiation will be controlled from the FEL Control Room rather than the
MCC due to the use of some specialized diagnostic equipment and cabling for
the equipment.
- Warm target will require 8-10 hours of 2 ľA irradiation, and cold
targets will require 5-6 hours of 2 ľA irradiation.
- A ceramic viewer with a hole, along with a monitoring camera, will be
installed to monitor beam position on the target. CTR may be sufficient to
look at the whole beam profile (we'll see tonight). The ceramic will
tolerate up to 80 ľA current.
- Target irradiation does not require precise delivery of dosage. A
factor-of-two measurement of electron-beam current is more than sufficient.
We will therefore use the BCM cavity on the linac as the principal current
monitor. It was tested this week with beam and "calibrated" against the
picoammeters on the straight-ahead dump.
- The cold dewar will be located at the downstairs elevator foyer until it
is needed in the beamline. The dewar needs to be topped off about every 8
hours. When the dewar is moved into the vault, we will not have both
access doors closed with the dewar and a person inside (for ODH safety).
Rather, one door will remain open in the process, which is eminently doable
since at least two people will be involved.
- An approximately uniform beam (at the 10% level) is needed across the
target. We will therefore leave the raster magnet on during irradiation,
per our original plan.
- Everyone is looking forward to the upcoming activity. The discussion
was very good.
L. Merminga followed with a presentation of beam-breakup (BBU) modeling
results given the latest measurements of higher-order modes in the
cryomodule. The simulations were for two passes with energy recovery. The
threshold current is calculated to be about 25-30 mA. Accordingly, we
might be able to tune the HOMs in such a way as to "make" BBU for
observation and experiments. During nominal operation with 5 mA beam, BBU
should not be a problem. D. Douglas indicated it may be possible to run
with three passes and amplify the BBU by another factor of order two, so
there are interesting possibilities for experiments. Ultimately, the
interest is ascertaining what is a sufficient safety margin with regard to
BBU when one designs higher-current machines.
New Issues
This is not really a new issue, but it was emphasized today that we need to
work out how and when to transition to the MCC for FEL commissioning.
Following GEN, the program is to proceed with injector setup for
first-light beam, then linac setup for first-light beam. A general
question arose as to which diagnostics can presently be implemented from
the MCC and which cannot. We will be working through this question in the
immediate future. Plans are to transition to the MCC as soon as possible.
R. Lauze indicated that there are six new operator postings, and so
operator availability for the FEL is likely to improve gradually.
New Action Items
- Hofler: Recheck software link between FLOG and FEL shift summaries.
(due 25 Mar 98)
Old Action Items
- Douglas/Karn: Ready the oval first-light air core correctors for
installation. Status: Karn is planning to begin magnet measurements next
week. (due 26 Mar 98 -- with some flexibility)
- Li: Explore implications of 60 pC settings for CSR experiments.
Status: Li now has some preliminary simulation results around the first
recirculation arc. She will continue and give an update at next week's
meeting. (due 27 Mar 98)
- Yunn/Jordan: Prepare, label, and post to the "FEL operator page" viewer
images of PARMELA beam for the optimized 60 pC setup. Status: Viewer
images for the injection line and injector dump line are posted. Yunn and
Douglas are working together on linac viewer images. There are hard copies
in the FEL Control Room, but to date not all viewer images are posted on
the operator page. (due 27 Mar 98)
- Jordan: Prepare procedure "MPS/BLM Checkout for First Light". Status:
Was awaiting completion of the MPS. There is still some uncertainty in the
MPS configuration/implementation that will be worked out next week, though
at present the MPS is running and will support first- light electron beam.
Jordan will get to work on the procedure. (due 27 Mar 98)
- Yunn/Jordan: Prepare, label, and post to the "FEL operator page" viewer
images of zero-current PARMELA beam given the optimized 60 pC setup.
Status: Hard-copies of the viewer images for the injection line and
injector dump line are in the FEL Control Room, and D. Douglas's
spreadsheet plots linac viewer images. They still need posting on the
operator page. (due 27 Mar 98)
Procedures in Work
Emittance Growth from CSR
- Tomographic Phase-Space Map Piot, 15 May 98
- Back Leg Thread Douglas, 6 Mar 98
Thread Beam around Machine, Top-Level Douglas, finalize 6 Mar 98
RF Stability during Energy Recovery Merminga, 6 Mar 98
MPS/BLM Checkout for First Light Jordan, 27 Mar 98
(Note: The highest-priority item here is the procedure for MPS/BLM
Checkout for First Light!)