What I thought the code was doing currently is the following:
Celeg produces MCTK and MCVX banks.
GSIM reads the PART bank, if it is not found it will use the MCTK and MCVX.
RECSIS reads the output of GSIM producing a PART bank, it keeps MCTK and
MCVX banks if they already exist.
In this scheme, after running Celeg -> gsim -> recsis I can compare the MCTK
bank from Celeg (what I started with) to the PART bank I finally ended up
with.
If I want to run: Data -> RECSIS -> GSIM
Then GSIM reads the PART bank and I can check whether particles actually
found in the data also make it through the Monte Carlo.
In the first scenario, it may actually be preferred that celeg produce MCTK
and MCVX banks. Which also saves you from making any changes to PART or the
way GSIM reads it's input.
So in the end, I think it may be better for reanalysing data that had been
through recsis if we leave things as they are. I would like to see if our
PWA friends have any comments on this.
Best Regards,
Maurik
John Price wrote:
>
> stepanya wrote:
> > I some how miss the point, why do you need PART in CELEG?
> > What is wrong with MCTK?
>
> The short answer: there's nothing "wrong" with the MCTK bank.
>
> This all came about when we started planning to have GSIM re-analyze
> data that had been through RECSIS, as part of a consistency check.
> Since it didn't make (largely) pedagogical sense to have RECSIS produce
> the MCTK and MCVX bank, the PART bank was born. Having celeg produce
> the PART bank is just another step in the same process.
>
> I have no intention of removing the MCTK bank from celeg. I am only
> producing the PART bank to make it easier for the people doing this
> study.
>
> --
> John Price *** *** *** *** pricej@jlab.org
> Where there is no solution, there is no problem.
--
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maurik Holtrop web: http://www.physics.unh.edu/Maurik
UNH Physics Department tel: (603) 862-2019 | fax: (603) 862-2998
DeMeritt Hall mailto:maurik.holtrop@unh.edu
Durham, NH 03824 Home: (603) 659-8765
----------------------------------------------------------------------