Privacy and Security Notice

delta_cuts

Analysis with tight delta cuts 04/30/06

Regions of phase space could be selected where Pauli blocking and FSI have less of an effect on the results.  The idea was to be able to rescue our deuterium data, which seems to be very model dependent, and make the ratios with hydrogen more significant. 

Basically, the idea is to sacrifice some statistics to reduce the model uncertainty.

Delta cuts were used to select low hsdelta and ssdelta events, so that the recoiling neutron has, on average, larger momentum.  The results in this region of phase space are less dependent on the model for Pauli blocking and FSI.  In hindsight, a more appropriate cut may be on the missing mass, which is also closely related to the neutron momentum.  A suitable cut might be mmx>0.96, for example.  However, with the delta cuts only, we can check that the missing mass distribution is not shifted between data and SIMC.

The missing mass shifts for all targets, except for gold, seem to have good agreement without any missing mass shifts.  I think it is exciting that the distributions (omega, Q2, thetapq, etc) seem to have good agreement between SIMC and the data.  Furthermore, the SIMC distributions do not really change much when Pauli blocking and FSI are turned on.  One notable exception is the deuterium missing mass plots at the lowest Q2 (no Pauli or fsi, with Pauli and FSI).  So, this setting may not be able to be rescued with this approach, unless we can make corrections to our Pauli blocking model for deuterium.

Conclusions:  With either tight delta cuts or a suitable missing mass cut, we seem to be select samples of events with reduced model uncertainty.  The lowest Q2 deuterium setting and the gold data appears to be the exceptions.

Results without missing mass shifts, Pauli blocking or FSI weight

NUCLEON mmx cuts 2H C
Al
Cu
Au Transp.
A/2H
A/C
A/Cu
Alpha
Alpha (H_to_Al)
Alpha (Al_to_Au)
Missmass cuts by eye
2H C Al Cu Au Transp. A/2H A/C A/Cu Alpha Alpha (H_to_Al) Alpha (Al_to_Au)
 Missing mass plots
mmx shift
2H C Al Cu Au
missmass shift
2H C Al Cu Au

Results without missing mass shifts, but with Pauli blocking and FSI weight (delta=2.0)
NUCLEON mmx cuts 2H C
Al
Cu
Au Transp.
A/2H
A/C
A/Cu
Alpha
Alpha (H_to_Al)
Alpha (Al_to_Au)
Missmass cuts by eye
2H C Al Cu Au Transp. A/2H A/C A/Cu Alpha Alpha (H_to_Al) Alpha (Al_to_Au)
  Missing mass plots
mmx shift
2H C Al Cu Au
missmass shift
2H C Al Cu Au